What Is Dog Reactivity? Fear, Big Feelings, and the Science Behind “Overreactions”

Most families meet “reactivity” on the sidewalk: a trigger appears, a dog barks and lunges, and it feels like the training vanished. It’s scary and isolating, but it’s not your dog being stubborn or “dominant.” It’s the nervous system saying: “This is too much.”

This post explains what reactivity and fear are, scientifically and practically, so you can see your dog with clearer eyes and make kinder, smarter choices.

What Do We Mean by “Reactive Dog”?

“Reactivity” gets used in lots of ways. For clarity in this series, we’ll use a practical, science-informed definition:

Reactivity means the dog’s emotional response becomes so strong that they can’t think or respond normally — their brain switches from purposeful behaviour to pure survival.

When a trigger appears, your dog’s flexible, purposeful behaviour (walk, sniff, take food, look at you) drops out. Survival responses take over: bark/lunge, freeze, or flee. That temporary loss of goal-directed behaviour is the hallmark of a reactive response.

Two important notes for families:

• We treat “reactive,” “fearful,” and “impulsive” as characteristics, not permanent identities. Your dog isn’t a label; they’re a learner whose nervous system needs help.

• “Reactive” does not automatically mean “aggressive.” Aggression involves intent to harm. Reactivity is usually a distance-increasing strategy or emotional overflow.

  
  

Fear vs. Behaviour: Why “He Knows Sit” Doesn’t Matter When He’s Scared

First, it’s important to know that fear is an emotion, not a behaviour. Emotions are what create behaviour, but they aren’t something a dog chooses or controls, and we can’t “train out” an emotion with a command.

When we talk about fear or reactivity, we’re talking about what’s happening inside the dog’s body and brain, not just what we see on the outside. Modern research shows that emotions have four parts working together:

1. Physiological changes

This means what happens inside the body. When a dog feels afraid, their heart rate speeds up, breathing gets shallow, and stress hormones like adrenaline or cortisol rise. These changes prepare the body to react: to fight, flee, or freeze, even if the threat isn’t real.

2. Observable body language and behaviour

This is the part we can see. You might notice a closed mouth, stiff posture, tucked tail, or wide eyes. Some dogs bark or lunge; others crouch low or try to hide. All of these are outward signs of what’s happening internally; they’re not the problem themselves; they’re the communication of emotion.

3. Cognitive bias (how emotion changes perception)

Emotions also affect how an animal interprets the world. A dog in a negative or anxious state tends to expect bad things to happen, what scientists call a pessimistic bias. A relaxed or confident dog expects good things: an optimistic bias.

In simpler terms: when your dog is stressed, they assume “something bad is coming,” even if it isn’t. That belief shapes how they react.

4. Subjective experience (“feelings”)

This is the part we can’t measure directly: what it feels like to be scared, frustrated, or relieved. We can’t see those feelings on a chart, but we can infer them from the dog’s body, behaviour, and context. It’s the emotional world your dog lives in, and it deserves as much attention as their training cues.

Why this matters

When a dog flips from their thinking brain to their survival brain, they literally lose access to learned behaviours. It’s not that they forgot “sit” or “leave it.” It’s that their brain has moved into self-protection mode, just like a person who can’t think clearly in a moment of panic.

So, when your dog reacts, they aren’t being stubborn or testing you. They’re overwhelmed. The real work isn’t about forcing control; it’s about helping their nervous system feel safe enough to think again.

Where Reactivity Comes From

Reactivity never happens in a vacuum. It’s the product of biology, experience, and environment: a mix of factors that shape how a dog perceives the world.

1. Fear and Anxiety

Fear is the most common root of reactivity. Dogs that didn’t have enough positive exposure to the world during puppyhood can grow up unsure about normal things: men with hats, kids running, wheelchairs, or other dogs. If something once scared them (like being barked at or attacked), the brain quickly learns, “That thing = danger.” Every new sight of it reignites that fear.

2. Frustration and Over-Excitement

Some dogs aren’t scared; they’re just too excited. They want to greet, play, investigate, or chase, and the leash or fence stops them. That blocked energy turns into an outburst. We call this barrier frustration or leash reactivity. It’s not “aggressive,” but it’s still stressful for everyone involved.

3. Pain or Medical Issues

Dogs in pain have shorter fuses. Thyroid problems, arthritis, GI discomfort, or chronic ear infections can all lower a dog’s tolerance. When a dog who’s normally calm suddenly becomes reactive, always rule out pain first.

4. Genetics and Temperament

Some breeds and bloodlines are simply more sensitive or high-drive. Herding and guarding breeds, for example, were bred to notice every movement and sound. That natural alertness can become reactivity when the environment is overwhelming.

5. Lack of Early Socialization

Puppies have a short “socialization window” (around 3–18 weeks old) when their brain learns what’s normal and safe. If that window closes before they’ve had enough gentle exposure to people, dogs, and environments, unfamiliar things can later trigger fear.

6. Previous Trauma

A single frightening event can change the brain. If a dog is attacked, yelled at, or hurt, they may form a lasting emotional memory; the next similar situation triggers panic before logic can intervene.

7. Unclear Training or Over-Exposure

Dogs need to learn how to cope with stimulation. Without structure or calm practice in low-distraction settings, everyday life can become too much. That’s why obedience cues alone don’t fix reactivity! This isn’t disobedience, it’s emotion regulation.

Fear vs. Anxiety — What’s the Difference?

• Fear is about something that’s happening right now (for example, a loud noise or a dog too close).

• Anxiety is about what might happen next (for example, worrying a dog will appear again).

In real life, those feelings overlap — and we don’t need to obsess about which word fits. Both tell us the same thing: the dog feels unsafe and needs help before they can learn or relax.

The Science of “Too Much”

In every reactive episode, three forces work together:

1. Arousal — the body floods with adrenaline.

2. Threshold — the point where the dog can no longer think clearly.

3. Learning — what happens right after determines what sticks.

If barking makes the trigger go away, the dog’s brain records a win.

Relief = reward. That’s called negative reinforcement — and it’s why reactivity repeats itself.

Understanding that process changes everything. Instead of fighting against emotion, we start teaching the dog how to feel safe again.

Reactivity vs. Aggression: How to Tell the Difference (and Why It Matters)

These two get mixed up all the time. The mix-up leads to the wrong plan, and sometimes to unfair labels for good dogs who are simply overwhelmed. Here’s a clean way to understand it.

Quick definitions (plain language)

• Reactivity = a big emotional response to a trigger. And as we discussed before, it’s usually driven by fear, anxiety, frustration, or over-excitement, not by a plan to hurt anyone. The classic “reactive look” is barking, lunging, growling, or freezing that stops once the scary or exciting thing gives space. In other words, the message is “I’m overwhelmed, please back off” or “I can’t get to that thing and I’m frustrated.”

• Aggression = behaviour meant to threaten or cause harm. Biting, attacking, or pursuing when the other party retreats are signs that the dog’s goal is more than “make space.” Aggression can be normal in some contexts (e.g., a mother protecting puppies or a true intruder), but the intent is different from reactivity.

The functional difference (what the dog is trying to achieve)

• Reactive dogs seek distance or relief. Once the trigger passes or space increases, they settle.

• Aggressive behaviour seeks to confront or control. The dog may pursue or re-engage even when the other party backs off.

Reactivity and aggression can overlap

A reactive dog can bite if trapped, ignored, or repeatedly pushed past warning signs. If biting reliably ends the situation, the dog can learn to use it sooner next time. That’s how untreated reactivity can drift into defensive aggression. This is why we take reactivity seriously and work under threshold.

Context and proportionality matter

• Appropriate aggression: A dog biting a genuine intruder is aggressive, but contextually normal.

• Overreaction (reactivity): A dog exploding at a harmless passerby is an emotional overreaction to a low-risk situation.

• Ask: “Given the situation, was the response proportional?” and “Did the dog want distance or a fight?”

If the dog could leave, would they?

• Reactive/fearful dogs usually choose flight over fight if given a safe option.

• Aggressive responses often persist or escalate even when the trigger retreats (e.g., chasing beyond the yard line).

Practical field guide (what families can watch for)

• Likely reactivity

  • Big display that stops when space increases

  • The dog can return to food/engagement once the trigger is gone

  • Pattern linked to leash or barrier (frustration makes it louder)

• Concerned about aggression

  • Pursuit after the trigger retreats

  • Targeted, repeated bites (not just air snaps)

  • No de-escalation, even when given distance

(Note: pain, medical issues, and chronic stress can push any dog toward more extreme behaviour. Always rule out health.)

The takeaway for your plan

• With reactivity, we focus on emotion change (feels safer), predictable space, and replacement patterns (look → treat → disengage).

• With true aggression, we keep the same humane methods but add tighter safety management (muzzle training, controlled setups) and often involve a qualified professional sooner.

The hopeful part

Most “aggressive-looking” moments on sidewalks are actually reactivity, not a desire to harm. When we address the underlying feelings (fear, frustration) and stop rehearsals, dogs improve—often dramatically. “Reactive” is not a life sentence; it’s a signal that the nervous system needs help.

What Families Need to Know

Your reactive dog isn’t giving you a hard time — they’re having a hard time. Their behaviour is a signal, not defiance.

You can help them by:

• learning to spot early stress signals (lip licking, stiff posture, sudden stillness);

• creating space before they hit the threshold;

• and rebuilding positive associations through controlled, reward-based exposure.

The next posts in this series will dive into the how:

• why leashes make reactions worse,

• how to use distance and calm repetition to change emotions,

• and the specific science-based methods (like desensitization and counterconditioning) that bring real change.

  
  

Want help understanding your own dog’s reactivity?

Join my mailing list for upcoming deep-dives on leash reactivity, recovery, and emotional resilience — plus early access to my behaviour workshops.

Keywords included

canine reactivity, reactive dog, fear-based reactivity, leash reactivity, barrier frustration, dog behaviour, dog aggression vs reactivity, dog threshold, trigger stacking, dog anxiety

Subscribe